From Proudhon to Lévi-Strauss And Beyond – A Dialogue Between Anarchism and Indigenous America

Autumn 2018

I will present a theoretical framework to open a dialogue between Amerindian and anarchist political forms through anthropology, highlighting an anarchist influence on the discipline and the contributions this dialogue can offer both anarchism and anthropology. I will point out similarities between Pierre-Joseph Proudhon’s and Claude Lévi-Strauss’ dialectics, suggesting that the first self-declared anarchist may have strongly influenced the Americanist anthropologist. Nevertheless, indigenous American peoples show their influence in Lévi-Strauss work by adding to it eccentric anti-unitarian perspectives. These comparisons unfold in the study of the ‘federative principle’ through Proudhon’s ‘political dualism’ and in the ‘dualism in perpetual imbalance made politics’ investigated by Beatriz Perrone-Moisés and Renato Sztutman in Amerindian cosmopolitics. Some key Amerindian deviations from politics are found to contribute critically to anarchist organisation and theory. I pay special attention to the way of life and thought of the A’uwe-Xavante people, with whom I have done ethnographic research, focusing particularly on kinship, gender, generations and game play.

PDF of article:

Subscribers to Anarchist Studies can access this article for free. If you are already a subscriber please login to your account to read the article.

Subscribe to Anarchist Studies

Please note that due to EU VAT charges on digital products, the final price may be slightly different depending on the EU country in which your billing address is located.